CSS Overflow Module Level 3

Status: ED
Work Status: Exploring
ED: https://drafts.csswg.org/css-overflow/
Shortname: css-overflow
Group: csswg
Level: 3
TR: https://www.w3.org/TR/css-overflow-3/
Previous version: https://www.w3.org/TR/2013/WD-css-overflow-3-20130418/
Editor: L. David Baron, Mozilla, http://dbaron.org/
Editor: Florian Rivoal, On behalf of Bloomberg, florian@rivoal.net, http://florian.rivoal.net/
Abstract: This module contains the features of CSS relating to scrollable overflow handling in visual media.
!Change Log: from 27 January 2015 to the present
!Change Log: from 28 March 2013 to 27 January 2015
!Change Log: from 31 July 2012 to 27 March 2013
Ignored Vars: B, P
Ignored Terms: padding edge

spec:css-transforms-1; type:property; text:transform-style
type: dfn; spec:css-multicol-1; text:overflow column

url: https://www.w3.org/TR/2008/CR-css3-marquee-20081205/#the-overflow-style; type: property; text: overflow-style;

Introduction

In CSS Level 1 [[CSS1]], placing more content than would fit inside an element with a specified size was generally an authoring error. Doing so caused the content to extend outside the bounds of the element, which would likely cause that content to overlap with other elements. CSS Level 2 [[CSS21]] introduced the 'overflow' property, which allows authors to have overflow be handled by scrolling, which means it is no longer an authoring error. It also allows authors to specify that overflow is handled by clipping, which makes sense when the author's intent is that the content not be shown. This specification introduces the long-standing de-facto 'overflow-x' and 'overflow-y' properties, and defines overflow handling more fully. [Something something 'max-lines'.]

Types of overflow

CSS uses the term overflow to describe the contents of a box that extend outside one of that box's edges (i.e., its content edge, padding edge, border edge, or margin edge). The term might be interpreted as elements or features that cause this overflow, the non-rectangular region occupied by these features, or, more commonly, the minimal rectangle that bounds that region. A box's overflow is computed based on the layout and styling of the box itself and of all descendants whose containing block chain includes the box. In most cases, overflow can be computed for any box from the bounds and properties of that box itself, plus the overflow of each of its children. However, this is not always the case; for example, when ''transform-style: preserve-3d'' [[CSS3-TRANSFORMS]] is used on some of the children, any of their descendants with ''transform-style: preserve-3d'' must also be examined. There are three different types of overflow, which are used for different purposes by the UA:

ink overflow
scrollable overflow
border-box overflow

Ink overflow

The ink overflow of a box is the part of that box and its contents that creates a visual effect outside of the box's border box. Ink overflow is the overflow of painting effects defined to not affect layout or otherwise extend the scrollable overflow region, such as box shadows, border images, text decoration, overhanging glyphs (with negative side bearings, or with ascenders/descenders extending outside the em box), outlines, etc. Issue: What about 'hanging-punctuation'? Since some effects in CSS (for example, the blurs in 'text-shadow' [[CSS3TEXT]] and 'box-shadow' [[CSS3BG]]) do not define what visual extent they cover, the extent of the ink overflow is undefined. The ink overflow region is the non-rectangular area occupied by the ink overflow, and the ink overflow rectangle is the minimal rectangle whose axis is aligned to the box's axes and contains the ink overflow region. Note that the ink overflow rectangle is a rectangle in the box's coordinate system, but might be non-rectangular in other coordinate systems due to transforms [[CSS3-TRANSFORMS]].

Scrollable overflow

The scrollable overflow of a box is the set of things extending outside of that box's padding edge for which a scrolling mechanism needs to be provided. The scrollable overflow region is the non-rectangular region occupied by the scrollable overflow, and the scrollable overflow rectangle is the minimal rectangle whose axis is aligned to the box's axes and contains the scrollable overflow region. The scrollable overflow region is the union of:

the box’s own content and padding areas
all line boxes directly contained by the box
the margin boxes unioned with the border boxes of all boxes for which it is the containing block (accounting for transforms as described below). Issue: Only Blink (and presumably WebKit) use the margin box for abspos; other browsers use the border box. Can we convince everyone else to change? Because using the border box is kindof hostile.
the scrollable overflow regions of all of the above boxes (accounting for transforms as described below), provided they themselves have ''overflow: visible'' (i.e. do not themselves trap the overflow) and that overflow is not already clipped by the 'clip' property. Note: The 'masking' properties do not affect the scrollable overflow region. Issue: Need to evaluate compat of honoring or ignoring 'clip' and 'clip-path'.

The following definition should be rewritten to use the concept of 3D rendering context [[!CSS3-TRANSFORMS]] and related terms, particularly once those concepts stabilize following changes proposed in the CSS WG meeting on the morning of 2014-01-28. Given the following definitions which belong in [[CSS3-TRANSFORMS]]:

3d-preserving child: A child box B of a containing block C is a 3d-preserving child if it has ''transform-style: preserve-3d'' and the user-agent is not required to flatten it based on the requirements in [[!CSS3-TRANSFORMS]].
non-3d-preserving child: A child C of a box P is a non-3d-preserving-child if it is not a 3d-preserving child.
3d-preserving descendant: Box D is a 3d-preserving descendant of box A if A is an ancestor of D, and D and all of the boxes (if any) in the containing block chain from D to A are 3d-preserving child boxes.

The scrollable overflow of a box is the union of the following things, all adjusted for transforms undefined concept! into the box's coordinate space:

for the box and all of its 3d-preserving descendant boxes:
- the box's own padding edge (for the box itself) or border edge (for 3d-preserving descendant boxes)
- the bounds undefined term! of any text directly in the box
- MORE HERE!
for all the non-3d-preserving child boxes of the box and its 3d-preserving descendant boxes, the scrollable overflow of the box

I wrote this definition off the top of my head, so it can't possibly be right. It's missing tons of pieces!

The handling of preserve-3d subtrees here is probably wrong; the elements should probably count only towards the overflow of the element that flattens them. Note that the scrollable overflow rectangle is a always rectangle in the box's own coordinate system, but might be non-rectangular in other coordinate systems due to transforms [[CSS3-TRANSFORMS]]. Issue: Browsers seem to agree on using axis-aligned rectangles (in the element's own coord space) to determine overflow. This means scrollbars can appear when not actually necessary. See testcase (adjust the ''scale(.9)'' to ''scale(.7)'' to see the scrollbars disappear, as the blue grandchild is no longer growing the bounds of the green child). Is this behavior we want to spec, or is it something browsers would like to fix someday?

Border box overflow

This concept has been proposed for some uses, such as for determining what the 'outline' property goes around, and as the basis of a coordinate system for specifying clips and masks, but it's not clear if it's needed. The border-box overflow of a box is the union of the box's border edge and the border edges of the box's descendants.

If needed, define more formally, as for scrollable overflow above. (Maybe even share the definitions in an appropriate way!) The border-box overflow region is the non-rectangular region occupied by the border-box overflow, and the border-box overflow rectangle is the minimal rectangle whose axis is aligned to the box's axes and contains the border-box overflow region. Note that the border-box overflow rectangle is a rectangle in the box's coordinate system, but might be non-rectangular in other coordinate systems due to transforms [[CSS3-TRANSFORMS]].

Scrollable Overflow: the 'overflow-x', 'overflow-y', and 'overflow' properties

These properties specify whether a box’s content (including any ink overflow) is clipped to its padding edge, and if so, whether it is a scroll container that allows the user to scroll clipped parts of its scrollable overflow region into view. The visual viewport of the scroll container (through which the scrollable overflow region can be viewed) coincides with its padding box, and is called the scrollport.

		Name: overflow-x, overflow-y
		Value: ''visible'' | ''hidden'' | ''clip'' | ''scroll'' | ''auto''
		Initial: ''visible''
		Applies to: block containers [[!CSS21]], flex containers [[!CSS3-FLEXBOX]], and grid containers [[!CSS3-GRID-LAYOUT]]
		Inherited: no
		Percentages: N/A
		Media: visual
		Computed value: see below
		Animatable: no

The 'overflow-x' property specifies the handling of overflow in the horizontal direction (i.e., overflow from the left and right sides of the box), and the 'overflow-y' property specifies the handling of overflow in the vertical direction (i.e., overflow from the top and bottom sides of the box).

		Name: overflow
		Value: ''visible'' | ''hidden'' | ''clip'' | ''scroll'' | ''auto''
		Initial: see individual properties
		Applies to: block containers [[!CSS21]], flex containers [[!CSS3-FLEXBOX]], and grid containers [[!CSS3-GRID-LAYOUT]]
		Inherited: no
		Percentages: N/A
		Media: visual
		Computed value: see individual properties
		Animatable: no
		Canonical order: per grammar

The 'overflow' property is a shorthand property that sets the specified values of both 'overflow-x' and 'overflow-y' to the value specified for 'overflow'. Values have the following meanings:

visible: There is no special handling of overflow, that is, it may be rendered outside the box. The box is not a scroll container.
hidden: This value indicates that the box’s content is clipped to its padding box and that no scrolling user interface should be provided by the UA to view the content outside the clipping region. However, the content may still be scrolled programatically, for example using the mechanisms defined in [[CSSOM-VIEW]], and the box is therefore still a scroll container.
clip: Like ''hidden'', this value indicates that the box’s content is clipped to its padding box and that no scrolling user interface should be provided by the UA to view the content outside the clipping region. In addition, unlike ''overflow: hidden'' which still allows programmatic scrolling, ''overflow: clip'' forbids scrolling entirely, through any mechanism, and therefore the box is not a scroll container. Issue: Mozilla implements -moz-hidden-unscrollable, which is similar to ''clip'', except that it does not cause the element to establish a BFC. Should we match that?
scroll: This value indicates that the content is clipped to the padding box, but can be scrolled into view (and therefore the box is a scroll container). Furthermore, if the user agent uses a scrolling mechanism that is visible on the screen (such as a scroll bar or a panner), that mechanism should be displayed whether or not any of its content is clipped. This avoids any problem with scrollbars appearing and disappearing in a dynamic environment. When this value is specified and the target medium is ''print'', overflowing content may be printed.
auto: This value indicates that the box’s content is clipped to the padding box, but can be scrolled into view (and therefore the box is a scroll container). However, if the user agent uses a scrolling mechanism that is visible on the screen (such as a scroll bar or a panner), that mechanism should only be displayed if there is overflow.

If the computed value of 'overflow' on a block box is not ''overflow/visible'', it creates a new block formatting context for its content.

Overflow Value Computation and Propagation

The computed values of 'overflow-x' and 'overflow-y' are determined from the specified values [[!CSS3CASCADE]] based on the following rules:

If one specified value is ''overflow/visible'' and the other is not, then computed values are the specified values with ''overflow/visible'' changed to ''overflow/auto''.
Otherwise, if both specified values are ''overflow/visible'' and the computed value of 'contain' is one that activates paint containment (e.g. ''contain:strict'' or ''contain: paint'' or ''contain: layout paint''…), then the computed values of both 'overflow-x' and 'overflow-y' are changed to ''overflow/clip''.
Otherwise, the computed values are as specified.

UAs must apply the 'overflow' property set on the root element to the viewport. For HTML UAs, if this would result in the viewport having ''visible'' overflow, the UA must instead apply the 'overflow' property set on the <{body}> element to the viewport. In either case, the used value of 'overflow' for the element from which the value is propagated must evaluate to ''visible''. If this application would result in the viewport having ''visible'' overflow, the UA must instead treat the viewport as having ''overflow/auto'' overflow.

Scrollbars and Layout

In the case of a scrollbar being placed on an edge of the element's box, it should be inserted between the inner border edge and the outer padding edge. Any space taken up by the scrollbars should be taken out of (subtracted from the dimensions of) the containing block formed by the element with the scrollbars. Issue: import examples from [[CSS3-BOX]].

Scrolling Origin, Direction, and Restriction

The initial scroll position, that is, the initial position of the box’s scrollable overflow region with respect to its border box, prior to any user or programmatic scrolling that changes it, is dependent on the box’s writing mode, and is by default the block-start/inline-start edge of the box’s padding edge. However, the 'align-content' and 'justify-content' properties [[!CSS-ALIGN-3]] can be used to change this. Due to Web-compatibility constraints (caused by authors exploiting legacy bugs to surreptitiously hide content from visual readers but not search engines and/or speech output), UAs must clip the scrollable overflow region of scroll containers on the block-start and inline-start sides of the box (thereby behaving as if they had no scrollable overflow on that side). The viewport uses the principal writing mode for these calculations.

[[CSS3-MARQUEE]] describes an 'overflow-style' property, but it has not picked up implementation experience that the working group is aware of. Should this document treat 'overflow-style' as a defunct proposal, or should this document describe the 'overflow-style' property and attempt to revive it, despite that implementations have implemented 'overflow-x' and 'overflow-y' instead?

Limiting Number of Visible Text Lines: the 'max-lines' property

		Name: max-lines
		Value: none | <>
		Initial: none
		Applies to: all non-inline elements
		Inherited: no
		Animatable: as integer
		Percentages: N/A
		Media: visual
		Computed value: specified value

Issue: Add back 'max-lines', so we can kill the unspecified WebKit feature that does this poorly.

Overflow in static media

This specification should define useful behavior for all values of 'overflow' in static media (such as print). Current implementation behavior is quite poor and produces unexpected results when authors have not considered what will happen when the content they produce for interactive media is printed. Privacy and Security Considerations {#priv-sec} =============================================== This specification introduces no new privacy or security concerns.

Acknowledgments

Thanks especially to the feedback from Rossen Atanassov, Bert Bos, Tantek Çelik, John Daggett, fantasai, Daniel Glazman, Vincent Hardy, Håkon Wium Lie, Peter Linss, Robert O'Callahan, Florian Rivoal, Alan Stearns, Steve Zilles, and all the rest of the www-style community.