Skip to content

Commit c21cf84

Browse files
authored
add+clarify cursor auto change detail; link issue
1 parent f18fe8f commit c21cf84

File tree

1 file changed

+9
-5
lines changed

1 file changed

+9
-5
lines changed

css-ui-3/transition-pr-2017-11.md

+9-5
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -27,7 +27,7 @@ First Tuesday or Thursday after a sucessful transition decision.
2727
## Changes
2828

2929
[Changes since the 2017-10-25 Candidate Recommendation](https://drafts.csswg.org/css-ui-3/#changes)
30-
<!-- no substantive chnges -->
30+
<!-- no substantive changes -->
3131

3232
The following changes were judged by the CSS-WG to be within the bounds allowed for a CR->PR transition:
3333

@@ -36,12 +36,16 @@ The following changes were judged by the CSS-WG to be within the bounds allowed
3636
* Allow, but stop requiring support for SVG images without intrinsic sizes for cursors (corresponding test update).
3737
* Align the spec with implementations, and make cursor: auto look like text over selectable text, and over editable elements (corresponding tests).
3838

39-
These are normative changes, but they are small tweaks to take into account implementation feedback on a few subtleties of the features.
39+
These are normative changes, but they are all based on feedback from actual implementations on a few subtleties of how they had implemented the features.
4040

41-
The first 3 changes cannot make an implementation that conformed to the spec prior to the changes become non conformant.
41+
The first 3 changes are are small tweaks and cannot make an implementation that conformed to the spec prior to the changes become non-conformant.
4242

43-
The 4th one arguably could, but implementations were in violation of the spec prior to the change (and not willing to align),
44-
while we have more than 2 test-passing implementations after the change with the rest being willing to align.
43+
The 4th change could theoretically impact conformance, but in practice does not.
44+
Zero known implementations (Gecko/Edge/Webkit/Blink/Presto) conformed with the previous wording (the [issue 1598 was openly reviewed and discussed](https://github.com/w3c/csswg-drafts/issues/1598) for several months),
45+
while multiple implementations pass tests and interoperate with the change,
46+
and all others for which conformance was not affected (did not pass before or after) agreed to update to conform to the new wording (over the old).
47+
48+
Thus the editors and WG believe all four normative changes fall within the bounds allowed for a CR->PR transition.
4549

4650
## Requirements satisfied
4751

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)