[css-values] Should trigonometric functions work outside of calc?

[Antonio-Laguna]

Hey there!

I've been reading the spec for trigonometric functions to implement them on PostCSS Preset Env.

From reading the spec it's not clear that functions shouldn't work only on calc(). pi and e for example have a special note:

Note: These keywords are only usable within a calculation, such as calc(pow(e, pi) - pi), or min(pi, 5, e). If used outside of a calculation, they’re treated like any other keyword: animation-name: pi; refers to an animation named "pi"; line-height: e; is invalid (not similar to line-height: 2.7, but line-height: calc(e); is).

Webkit's implementation only allows to use inverse trigonometric outside of calc since they resolve to deg however, even if odd, should it be possible to do line-height: sin(45deg) given that it resolves to .707?

[tabatkins]

Correct, all the math functions resolve to whatever their types are defined as, and are usable anywhere that accepts those types. Your 'line-height' example is perfectly valid per spec; if WebKit isn't allowing that, it's a bug in their implementation.