Nutritional Medicine First Edition Alan Gaby MD Download
Nutritional Medicine First Edition Alan Gaby MD Download
download
https://ebookname.com/product/nutritional-medicine-first-edition-
alan-gaby-md/
Get the full ebook with Bonus Features for a Better Reading Experience on ebookname.com
Instant digital products (PDF, ePub, MOBI) available
Download now and explore formats that suit you...
https://ebookname.com/product/nutritional-and-integrative-
strategies-in-cardiovascular-medicine-1st-edition-stephen-t-
sinatra/
https://ebookname.com/product/diabetes-for-dummies-3rd-edition-
alan-l-rubin-md/
https://ebookname.com/product/diabetes-cookbook-for-dummies-3rd-
edition-alan-l-rubin-md/
https://ebookname.com/product/guidelines-for-music-therapy-
practice-in-developmental-health-1st-edition-michelle-r-hintz/
Advances in Marine Biology Vol 53 1st Edition David W.
Sims (Ed.)
https://ebookname.com/product/advances-in-marine-biology-
vol-53-1st-edition-david-w-sims-ed/
https://ebookname.com/product/the-dementias-early-diagnosis-and-
evaluation-1st-edition-karl-herholz/
https://ebookname.com/product/the-unofficial-lego-builder-s-
guide-1st-edition-allan-bedford/
https://ebookname.com/product/nelson-international-
mathematics-2nd-edition-student-book-3-op-primary-supplementary-
courses-morrison/
https://ebookname.com/product/your-personal-horoscope-
for-2003-joseph-polansky/
Common things romance and the aesthetics of belonging
in Atlantic modernity 1st Edition Lilley
https://ebookname.com/product/common-things-romance-and-the-
aesthetics-of-belonging-in-atlantic-modernity-1st-edition-lilley/
3 3440 00157366 -)
NUTRITIONAL
MEDICINE
“Alan R.. Gaby, M.D. |
ae
ae - i 2 ; ~
|
|
|
Digitized by the Internet Archive
in 2021 with funding from
Kahle/Austin Foundation
https://archive.org/details/nutritionalmedicO000gaby
NUTRITIONAL
MEDICINE
, €F>
i /f
Cc
f\ /\ r\
/\ r/ . J x
Copyright © 2011
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means, including photocopying, or
stored in a retrieval system. or transmitted in any form by any means, without written permission of the copyright owner.
WARNING/DISCLAIMER FOR NON-PRACTITIONERS: The information provided in this book is for educational
purposes only, and should not be construed as personal medical advice or instruction. No action should be taken based
solely on the contents of this book. Readers should consult appropriate health professionals on any matter relating to their
health and well-being. Readers who fail to consult appropriate health authorities assume the risk of any injuries. The
author and publisher are not responsible for errors or omissions.
Note: Errata will be posted at www.doctorgaby.com. If you detect an error, please send an email to Nutrition@doctorgaby.com.
ISBN-13: 978-0-9828850-0-0
ISBN-10: 0-9828850-0-8
To purchase additional copies of this book, visit www.doctorgaby.com, or call 603-225-0134. or write to Nutritional
Medicine, 12 Spaulding Street, Concord, NH 03301.
Fritz Perlberg and Bonnie Raindrop, who for more than 25 years
provided encouragement and helpful ideas that helped me bring
this work to completion.
Foreword (Bill Manahan, M.D.) el 3) Silicon 176-177
Foreword (Jonathan V. Wright, M.D.) Xiil 38 Boron 178-179
Introduction XV 5M) Molybdenum 179-180
40 Nickel 181
Part 1. FUNDAMENTALS OF NUTRITIONAL
MEDICINE Part 2C. AMINO ACIDS
Overview of nutritional medicine 1-3 41 L-Arginine 182-184
Fundamentals of diet 3-8 42 L-Glutamine 184-185
Sucrose and high-fructose corn syrup 8-10 43 L-Lysine 186-187
Food additives 10-14 44 L-Methionine 187-189
Cooking and storage of foods 14-18 45 Phenylalanine 189-191
Reactive hypoglycemia 19-23 46 Taurine 191-192
Food allergy 23-28 47 L-Tryptophan 192-195
Hypothyroidism 28-40 48 5-Hydroxytryptophan (5-HTP) 195-196
WNCandidiasis (Candida-related
OmAANNDNF 49 L-Tyrosine 196-198
complex) 40-46
10 Orthomolecular medicine 46-49 Part 2D. OTHER THERAPEUTIC AGENTS
50 Acetyl-L-carnitine 198
Part 2. THERAPEUTIC AGENTS 51 N-Acetylcysteine 199-200
Introduction to therapeutic agents 51-52 52 Azelaic acid 200-201
Part 2A. VITAMINS 53 Betaine 201-202
11 Vitamin A 533-59 54 Carnitine 202-205
12 Beta-carotene 60-62 55 Coenzyme Qio 205-207
13 Thiamine 62-66 56 Dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) 208-211
14 Riboflavin 66-68 57 Dietary fiber 211-214
15 Vitamin B; Goo. 58 Flavonoids 214-216
16 Folate (folic acid) 72-18 59 Selected herbal remedies 216-219
17 Pantothenic acid 78-79 60 Inositol 219-221
18 Vitamin Be 80-87 61 Inositol hexanicotinate 221
19 Biotin 87-89 62 Alpha-lipoic acid 222-223
20 Vitamin Bj> 89-96 63 Lutein and zeaxanthin 223
21 Choline 97-99 64 Lycopene 224-225
22 Vitamin C 99-108 65 Melatonin 225-226
23 Vitamin D 108-117 66 Omega-3 fatty acids 227-230
24 Vitamin E 117-125 67 Omega-6 fatty acids 230-234
25 Vitamin K 125-129 68 Pantethine 234-235
69 Para-aminobenzoic acid (PABA) 235-236
Part 2B. MINERALS 70. Probiotics 236-238
26 Calcium 129-134 71 S-Adenosylmethionine (SAMe) 238
27 Magnesium 134-140
28 Potassium 141-143 Part 3. CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE
29 Sodium 144-145 ie Angina pectoris 239-244
30 Iron 145-151 site. Aortic aneurysm 244-245
Sis Zine 151-158 74 Arrhythmias 245-250
32 Copper 159-162 75 Atherosclerosis and ischemic heart
33 Chromium 163-165 disease 250-274
34 Selenium 166-169 76 Cardiac arrest 274-275
35. Manganese 169-172 77 Cardiovascular risk factors:
36 Iodine 172-176 cholesterol 275-288
v1 CONTENTS
X1
a re
, y eGR gee44 : oyu ofl ite tree
. Atta, A& wire) ct ie Ves by wisinpipps o OL a
=e) apy ile & out) Om
rapiet i? bot ‘aueralad iver 6 VunRmy
mL a VER RED
a anja & mae
———
=a (cvee
Nutritional Medicine, by Alan R. Gaby, M.D., is a land- medicine was criticized and ridiculed as unscientific
mark, a milestone in the history of 21‘' century medicine. “quackery.”
The influence of this book will at first spread slowly, But in the decades since 1968, public acceptance of ortho-
mainly among the relatively few medical and osteopathic molecular medicine has greatly increased, usually under
doctors, dentists, and nurse practitioners who practice nat- other names including “natural medicine,” “alternative med-
ural medicine and holistic dentistry. It will be embraced icine,” and “integrative medicine.” The number of “health
by naturopathic physicians, chiropractic physicians, com- food” stores has increased dramatically. Every major gro-
pounding pharmacists, and many other “allied natural health cery chain has an organic food section, as well as an array
professionals’ —acupuncturists, massage therapists, health of vitamin and mineral products. Even the most main-
spa workers, heath food store owners—as well as the stream pharmacies have dramatically increased their vita-
educated public. People will sit up and take notice of Dr. min, mineral, and herbal offerings, too, and the Internet
Gaby’s very thorough documentation, the logic of his abounds with natural products for sale.
approach, and his clear writing. As word about the immense Academic research concerning the effects of naturally
amount of reliable and very useful information in this occurring molecules has increased exponentially since 1968.
book—which covers literally hundreds of topics from mul- When Dr. Gaby and I gave our first Nutritional Therapy in
tiple areas of medicine—gets out, copies will start flying Medical Practice seminar in 1983, our book of citations to
off the shelves. the scientific literature was slightly less than 80 pages, and
Sooner or later, this book will make its way into the included nearly every research article we could find. Our
offices of practicing mainstream physicians, who will cau- 2007 seminar book of citations included 372 pages, and
tiously try Dr. Gaby’s recommendations, test his conclu- lack of space forced us to exclude many more citations
sions, and discover that they actually work in practice. than were included. In 1983, we had no protocol book (a
Younger physicians will adopt more and more of his diag- book containing summaries of recommendations for each
nostic and treatment approaches. Students in “mainstream” disease condition). In 2007, our protocol book summariz-
medical schools wiil circulate this book and question their ing diet and nutrient recommendations for 119 distinct con-
professors, some of whom will open their eyes to the very ditions filled 68 pages.
real science it contains. Research papers in nutritional medicine have been Alan
Dr. Gaby’s Nutritional Medicine firmly establishes the Gaby’s passion since he was in medical school. I first heard
scientific basis for the use of diet, vitamins, minerals, amino from him in a letter from Maryland, where he was attend-
acids, essential fatty acids, and other important natural ing medical school in the late 1970s. He was interested in
metabolites (such as coenzyme Qj and alpha-lipoic acid). applying for a four-week elective in nutritional medicine
His book is a direct descendant and major elaboration of that I was offering to medical students at that time. He sent
Linus Pauling’s concept of orthomolecular medicine— me a copy of a review article he had written on the uses of
driven by the concept of preventing and treating illness magnesium in medical practice. He also told me about how
with “the right molecules in the right concentrations.” Paul- he had been “called on the carpet” by a professor of inter-
ing introduced the beginnings of this concept in a paper nal medicine at his medical school for expressing his views
entitled “Orthomolecular psychiatry,” published in the jour- about nutritional medicine. I thought the magnesium arti-
nal Science in 1968. In it, he outlined “the treatment of cle was well researched and well written, so I accepted
mental disease by the provision of the optimum molecular him for the elective. Later, Dr. Gaby joined my medical
environment for the mind, especially the optimum concen- practice for two years before returning to practice in his
trations of substances normally present in the body.” Paul- home town of Baltimore.
ing later enlarged his concept to orthomolecular medicine, In addition to seeing clinic patients, Dr. Gaby spent more
which he defined as “the preservation of good health and time in the medical library than anyone I’ve known before
the treatment of disease by varying the concentrations in or since. In the early 1980s, well prior to online research
the human body of substances that are normally present libraries, he spent 30 hours a week for more than two years
in the body.” Even though at that time orthomolecular med- going through the entire table of contents of 50 major med-
icine was being widely practiced without being called by ical journals back to 1920, and about 200 other journals
that name (for example, treating diabetes with insulin and back to their beginnings. He photocopied, categorized, and
preventing goiter with iodine), Pauling’s orthomolecular we jointly filed every important research article concern-
Xill
X1V FOREWORD
ing diet, vitamins, minerals, amino acids, essential fatty course), and there are a surprising number of citations to
acids, and other important natural substances ever pub- studies that were published only months before the manu-
lished in these journals. Subsequently, he organized a team script went to press. This book puts everything you need to
of students from Bastyr College of Naturopathic Medicine know about nutritional medicine right at your fingertips. In
(now Bastyr University) to finish the search of the older addition, there are some 15,000 references, just in case you
literature and to copy relevant new research studies as they want to explore Dr. Gaby’s reasoning further on a point or
were published. For over 25 years Dr. Gaby and I have two. To find things quickly, Nutritional Medicine has a
continued to pay similar teams of naturopathic students to comprehensive index.
“pull” new research papers every month. In addition to I wouldn’t be surprised if, after reading Nutritional Med-
these joint efforts, both of us have separate data- and article- icine, a fair and open-minded University medical school
collecting sources, both in print and online, and we share dean might consider offering Dr. Gaby the eminently well-
the ones that seem to be the best. At last count, our joint deserved position of Professor of Nutritional Medicine, if
physical research files contained over 50,000 articles. the Dean can convince the relevant faculty committee, of
But Dr. Gaby’s skills aren’t limited to researching and course. How about it, Dartmouth University Medical School?
seeing patients; he’s also an exceptionally knowledgeable After all, Dr. Gaby lives right there in New Hampshire!
and inspirational teacher. From 1979 to 1981, and then
from 1995 through 2002, he was Professor of Nutrition at July 11, 2010
Bastyr University School of Naturopathic Medicine. I’ve Jonathan V. Wright, M.D.
spoken to many of his former students, who’ve told me he Tahoma Clinic
was the best professor they encountered in their years of Renton, Washington
naturopathic medical school. He combines all of these www.tahomaclinic.com
skills—research, teaching and excellent writing—and brings www.wrightnewsletter.com
them to us in the pages of this book. Author, Dr. Wright's Book of Nutritional Therapy (1979)
Nutritional Medicine is a comprehensive review and syn- Author, Dr.Wright’s Guide to Healing with Nutrition (1984)
thesis of published science synthesized with real-world expe- Co-author (with Dr. Gaby), Natural Medicine,
rience, both Dr. Gaby’s own and that of trusted colleagues. Optimal Wellness (2006)
Alan has always been alert for new information and break- Author, Your Stomach (2009)
ing developments (if they appear scientifically reliable, of Co-author, 5 other books, 1997-2010
oe ee
. y>caer” ai eel +4,
NAC
In 1973, shortly after graduating from college, I became it lacks legitimacy. That assumption may be heightened fur-
interested in the possibility that dietary modifications, nutri- ther by the exaggerated claims made by some popular writ-
tional supplements, and other “natural” remedies could be ers and by some nutritional supplement manufacturers.
used as the basis for an approach to medical care that would Nutritional Medicine attempts to cut through the biases, mis-
be safer, less expensive, and sometimes more effective than interpretations, and misrepresentations of both the oppo-
the usual drugs-and-surgery approach. Pioneers such as Linus nents and proponents of this controversial field of medicine.
Pauling, Roger Williams, Abram Hoffer, and Adelle Davis Nutritional Medicine contains more than 15,000 refer-
had written about this concept. They argued that many dis- ence citations. While numerous double-blind trials have
eases could be prevented or treated by adjusting the con- been cited, also included are uncontrolled trials, case reports,
centration of molecules normally present in the body, such and anecdotal evidence. As a scientist, I am aware that
as vitamins, minerals, amino acids, and hormones. Although many nutritional treatments remain unproven according to
these writers cited hundreds of references to support their standard scientific criteria. However, as a practitioner and
point of view, this concept was rejected by the conven- public-health advocate, I am interested in safe and inexpen-
tional medical community. sive treatments that show promise, even if they have not
Since completing my medical training in 1980, I have been subjected to a double-blind trial. It is noteworthy that
Spent approximately one-third of my time seeing patients a relatively large number of conventional physicians, who
(emphasizing nutritional therapies) and two-thirds collect- had no professional interest in nutritional medicine, sought
ing and analyzing tens of thousands of published studies my treatments when they or one of their family members
that relate to nutritional medicine. Based on this combina- became ill.
tion of clinical experience and literature review, I am cer- While most of the research cited in Nutritional Medicine
tain that nutritional therapy has an important role to play is from the modern era, there are a number of references to
in the practice of medicine. Depending on the clinical sit- the medical literature from the 1950s, 1940s, and even ear-
uation, dietary modifications and nutritional supplements lier. Because I have included these older references, some
can frequently be used as an adjunct or an alternative to people have criticized my writing as being “outdated.” These
conventional therapies. Of the approximately 6,000 patients critics fail to appreciate that, over the years, many effec-
I have treated, many of whom had failed to respond to (or tive therapies were ignored or inappropriately cast aside,
had experienced adverse effects from) conventional ther- and that a great deal of promising research was never fol-
apy, approximately 80% obtained relief, in many cases dra- lowed up. For example, reports from 1946 and 1956 that
matic relief, from various nutritional treatments described riboflavin can prevent migraines were ignored or rapidly
in this book. Countless other physicians have told me that forgotten. More than 40 years passed before a new gener-
their results improved substantially after they began incor- ation of researchers, apparently unaware of the earlier
porating nutritional therapies into their practice. reports, again found riboflavin to be effective. However,
Although an extensive body of literature supports the value the value of riboflavin for migraine prophylaxis still remains
of nutritional therapy, this approach remains largely unknown virtually unknown in conventional medicine, despite a 1997
to the conventional medical community. One possible expla- double-blind trial and 2 uncontrolled trials (published in
nation for this is that the pharmaceutical industry exerts a 2004 and 1994) supporting its effectiveness. Similarly,
great deal of influence over medical education. This influ- between 1943 and 1968, the effectiveness of vitamin C as
ence might take the form of sponsoring continuing-education a treatment for prickly heat was discovered 3 times and
events that focus exclusively on pharmaceutical products; forgotten twice. It was apparently forgotten a third time,
funding research designed to show that alternative treat- since vitamin C is not currently mentioned in dermatology
ments are ineffective (see, for example, the discussion of textbooks or review articles as a treatment for prickly heat.
St. John’s wort in chapter 287); providing financial support This book is the result of more than 30 years of study,
to researchers who are likely to write negative review arti- contemplation, and experience. My hope is that it will help
cles about nutritional medicine; using the media to promul- promote better health, reduce the cost of healthcare, and
gate negative information about nutritional medicine; and stimulate further research in this promising and exciting
inundating doctors with sales reps and free samples, and field of medicine.
the public with drug advertisements. In addition, for rea-
sons that are not entirely clear, there appears to be an inher-
References
ent bias in academic medicine against micronutrient 1. Goodwin JS, Tangum MR. Battling quackery: attitudes about micronutri-
supplements.! Moreover, nutritional therapy is not taught in ent supplements in American academic medicine. Arch Intern Med 1998:158:
medical school, which leads many students to assume that 2187-2191.
XV
wa” Mess |.
bb's
v2
Ve y » je fa)
= . ‘ 1 Um one
7 Ae 9 ith '&
=
i tig
lie Se
‘ aL
t <i “ —
t
ey
. 7
=
, Se A is
f ‘
FUNDAMENTALS OF NUTRITIONAL MEDICINE.
Why nutritional medicine? immunological disorders frequently play a role in the patho-
genesis of a number of chronic health conditions. Iden-
Scientific research and clinical experience have shown that tification and appropriate treatment of these disorders is
dietary modifications and administration of nutrients and important for the successful practice of nutritional medi-
other natural substances are frequently effective for pre- cine. The first disorder, reactive hypoglycemia, is charac-
venting and treating a wide range of symptoms and ill- terized by abnormalities of blood glucose regulation, as
nesses. Moreover, when properly administered, nutritional well as other accompanying metabolic and endocrine dis-
therapy has an excellent safety profile and almost never turbances. Treatment of reactive hypoglycemia includes
causes serious side effects. The nutritional approach to pre- avoiding refined sugar, other refined carbohydrates, caf-
venting and treating disease rarely subjects patients to the feine, and alcohol; eating small, frequent meals; and sup-
unpleasant trade-offs inherent in many drug treatments, such plementing with vitamins, minerals, and other natural
as statin-induced myalgia in exchange for a lower risk of substances that aid in blood glucose regulation. The sec-
having a heart attack; beta blocker-induced loss of joie de ond common disorder is hidden food allergy. In many cases,
vivre in exchange for better control of heart failure; or identifying and avoiding allergenic foods can play a key
glucocorticoid-induced osteoporosis in exchange for relief role in restoring health. Third, a substantial minority of
of arthritic pain. To the contrary, many of the “side effects” patients appears to have subtle hypothyroidism, despite the
reported by patients who follow a nutritional program are presence of normal laboratory tests for thyroid function.
positive, such as more energy, better mood, fewer crav- These patients benefit from treatment with low doses of
ings, better mental concentration, and less aches and pains. thyroid hormone. Fourth is a clinical syndrome that has
been called candidiasis or Candida-related complex. This
The practice of nutritional medicine syndrome is characterized by an overgrowth of, or hyper-
sensitivity to, Candida albicans. Symptoms overlap with
The practice of nutritional medicine includes several main those caused by reactive hypoglycemia, food allergy, and
components, the relative importance of which varies from hypothyroidism. Treatment includes antifungal medication
one patient to another. For most patients, nutritional ther- and dietary modifications similar to those used for reactive
apy starts with “cleaning up the diet” by emphasizing a wide hypoglycemia and food allergy.
variety of whole, unprocessed foods and minimizing intake
of refined sugars, other refined carbohydrates, trans fatty Individualizing treatment. Nutritional medicine is highly
acids, food additives, and other undesirable constituents of individualized, and effective treatment varies from one
a typical Western diet. Restricting the use of salt, caffeine, patient to another. For example, some patients with chronic
and alcohol is also important for some individuals. In addi- fatigue respond best to dietary modifications such as avoid-
tion, emphasizing cooking methods that minimize the for- ing refined sugar and eating 6 small meals per day, or
mation of potentially toxic compounds (such as cholesterol identifying and avoiding allergenic foods. In other cases,
oxides, lipid peroxides, and advanced glycation end prod- the most effective treatment for fatigue is a low dose of
ucts) may be beneficial. Nutritional therapy also includes thyroid hormone or a specific nutritional supplement, such
the use of a wide array of vitamins, minerals, amino acids, as potassium magnesium aspartate, iron (to correct iron
deficiency), or intramuscular vitamin B,> (even in the
herbs, and other naturally occurring compounds, individu-
alized according to the patient’s needs. This “natural phar- absence of vitamin B,, deficiency). Frequently, the best
macopoeia” stands alongside the conventional pharmacopoeia results are achieved with a combination of interventions.
of prescription and over-the-counter drugs. Depending on
Clinical assessment. Determining which treatments are
the clinical situation, these natural substances can be used
most likely to be effective for a particular patient requires
as an adjunct or an alternative to conventional medicine.
a proper medical and dietary history, a good physical exam-
Hypoglycemia/allergy/hypothyroidism/Candida. In my ex- ination, and a working knowledge of the nutritional-
perience, four distinct but overlapping metabolic/endocrine i, medicine literature. Laboratory tests are essential in some
2 PART 1 * FUNDAMENTALS OF NUTRITIONAL MEDICINE
circumstances (as in diagnosing iron deficiency), but may inflammation and oxidative stress, thereby allowing nutri-
be of questionable validity or even misleading in other tional supplements to be used for processes other than
situations (as in identifying hidden food allergies or subtle mounting an inflammatory response and quenching free rad-
nutritional deficiencies). In practicing nutritional medicine, icals. In addition, certain nutrients enhance the absorption
I have rarely ordered laboratory tests other than those that or tissue uptake of other nutrients. For example, vitamin C
might be ordered by a conventional medical doctor. increases iron absorption and magnesium promotes the
uptake of potassium from serum into cells. Some nutrients
inhibit the degradation of other nutrients (e.g., flavonoids
Additive and synergistic effects decrease vitamin C requirements by preventing the oxida-
A recurring theme in nutritional medicine is that combina- tion of vitamin C).>° Furthermore, certain nutrients may
tions of interventions often have additive or synergistic relieve biochemical “bottlenecks” by activating parallel path-
effects, in that they are more effective than single inter- ways. For example, the conversion of homocysteine to
ventions. For example, combinations of nutrients may be methionine proceeds largely through a folate-dependent path-
more effective than individual nutrients; the beneficial effects way, but it may also proceed through a separate pathway
of dietary modifications are often more pronounced when that requires betaine. Similarly, multiple biochemical path-
combined with appropriate nutrients, hormones, and other ways exist to detoxify xenobiotic chemicals, bacterial tox-
natural substances; and the benefits of nutrients, hor- ins, and endogenous metabolites.
mones, and other natural substances are often more pro-
Synergy and the art of nutritional medicine. Because
nounced when patients also adhere to appropriate dietary
multiple nutritional interventions are often more effective
recommendations. A corollary to these observations is that
than a single treatment, practitioners may be tempted to
nutrients, hormones, and other natural substances are some-
“throw everything but the kitchen sink” at various medical
times effective at lower doses when they are used in
problems. However, nutritional “polypharmacy” is not with-
combination with other interventions than when they are
out potential drawbacks, including high cost to the patient,
given singly.
increased time and effort involved in following complex
Clinical observations regarding the existence of additive
treatment regimens, and the possibility that ingesting numer-
and synergistic effects are supported by both clinical and
ous tablets and capsules will cause gastrointestinal or other
basic-science research. For example, anemia has been found
side effects.
in some studies to respond better to multiple nutrients than
The art of nutritional medicine includes being able to
to a single nutrient. The combination of vitamin B. and
identify which dietary modifications and supplements are
magnesium was reported to be more effective than either
most likely to be beneficial for a particular patient, and
of these treatments alone in the treatment of autism. In
which interventions are more likely to be ineffective or
addition, the homocysteine-lowering effect of folic acid was
unnecessary. As with other healthcare disciplines, master-
enhanced by the addition of vitamin B,,.' In dermatology,
ing the art of nutritional medicine requires education, con-
vitamin E has been used to increase the therapeutic effect
templation, and practice. According to one of my mentors
of vitamin A. In healthy volunteers, the combination of
in medical school, Dr. Theodore Woodward, the better trained
vitamin C and vitamin E enhanced parameters of immune
you are, the fewer tests you will need to perform and the
function to a greater extent than did either of these nutri-
fewer medications you will need to prescribe. That princi-
ents individually.” In patients with a clinical picture sug-
ple also applies to nutritional medicine.
gestive of chronic candidiasis (chapter 9), symptoms
improved to a greater extent when dietary modification was
combined with nystatin therapy than when diet or nystatin How to use this book
were used alone.
In mice with experimentally induced atherosclerosis, com- Nutritional Medicine consists of two main types of chap-
bined supplementation with vitamin E and coenzyme Qj ters: those that discuss the prevention and treatment of
was more anti-atherogenic than was either supplement alone.* specific diseases or symptoms and those that provide infor-
In isolated rat hearts subjected to ischemia and reperfu- mation about the fundamentals and “tools” of nutritional
sion, various hemodynamic and metabolic abnormalities medicine (i.e., diet, therapeutic agents, and other treat-
were prevented by simultaneous administration of carni- ment modalities). Becoming proficient in the management
tine and coenzyme Qj, but not by administration of either of specific health conditions requires a working knowl-
of these nutrients individually.* edge of the fundamentals and tools. Therefore, in addition
to reviewing disease-specific chapters of interest, the reader
Possible mechanisms. There are a number of possible is urged to study the chapters in Part 1 (Fundamentals of
mechanisms by which dietary modifications and treatment nutritional medicine) and Part 2 (Therapeutic agents), as
with natural substances could have additive or synergistic well as chapters 340-342 (Intravenous nutrient therapy
effects. For example, dietary improvements might decrease and Drug-nutrient interactions). Part 1 includes chapters
CHAPTER | * OVERVIEW OF NUTRITIONAL MEDICINE 2
on reactive hypoglycemia, food allergy, hypothyroidism, likely to consider. These recommendations should be viewed
and candidiasis. It also includes a chapter on orthomolec- only as rough guidelines, not as established protocols.
ular medicine, which provides a rationale for the use of
nutritional supplements.
References
Disease-specific chapters. Some disease-specific chap- 1. Bronstrup A, Hages M, Prinz-Langenohl R, Pietrzik K. Effects of folic
acid and combinations of folic acid and vitamin B-12 on plasma homocys-
ters present a relatively large number of treatment options. teine concentrations in healthy, young women. Am J Clin Nutr 1998;68:
The choice of which treatments to use depends on several 1104-1110.
factors, including safety, magnitude of the effect, strength 2. Jeng KCG, Yang CS, Siu WY, et al. Supplementation with vitamins C and
E enhances cytokine production by peripheral blood mononuclear cells in
of the evidence, cost, and characteristics of the patient. healthy adults. Am J Clin Nutr 1996;64:960—965S.
When possible, I have attempted to prioritize the treatment 3. Thomas SR, Leichtweis SB, Pettersson K, et al. Dietary cosupplementa-
tion with vitamin E and coenzyme Q10 inhibits atherosclerosis in apolipopro-
options and to outline those patient characteristics that might tein E gene knockout mice. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 2001;21:
lead to the choice of certain treatment options over others. 585-593.
At the end of some chapters I have provided a summary 4. Bertelli A, Ronca F, Ronca G, et al. L-carnitine and coenzyme Q10 pro-
tective action against ischaemia and reperfusion of working rat heart. Drugs
of recommendations, a conclusion, or a review of my clin- Exp Clin Res 1992;18:431—436.
ical approach to the condition in question. These end-of- 5. Crampton EW, Lloyd LE. Quantitative estimation of effect of rutin on
biological potency of vitamin C. Fed Proc 1950;9:355—356.
chapter sections are designed to give the reader an idea of 6. Clemetson CAB, Andersen L. Plant polyphenols as antioxidants for ascor-
my thinking processes and of which treatments I am most bic acid. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1966;136:341-376.
Fundamentals of diet
This chapter provides basic information on the principles carbohydrates, fat, vitamins, and minerals. In addition, whole
of healthful eating. It also provides selected, clinically rel- foods contain fiber and a wide range of phytochemicals
evant information on the effects of specific foods and food that may have health benefits. These include flavonoids
groups. (which enhance tissue integrity), indole-3-carbinol (which
may help prevent cancer), lignans (compounds with possi-
ble anticancer activity that are present in the fiber compo-
Whole foods
nent some plants),! oligosaccharides (which support the
Dietary recommendations should be individualized for each growth of beneficial intestinal bacteria), sterols (which lower
patient, but certain basic principles apply to most people. serum cholesterol levels), hippuric acid (an antibiotic), and
A healthful diet should include a wide variety of whole, alkylresorcinols (see below). Each new scientific discovery
unprocessed foods that are free of additives and, if possi- regarding phytochemicals reminds us of the enormous com-
ble, grown without the use of pesticides, herbicides, and plexity of whole food and of the futility of attempting to
other potentially toxic agricultural chemicals. For people duplicate their effects with “nutraceutical” pills and potions.
who do not have specific food intolerances, such a diet
generally includes liberal amounts of fresh fruits and veg- Whole grains. Whole grains contain a wide range of vita-
etables, whole grains, nuts, seeds, and legumes. For most mins and minerals, as well as fiber, essential fatty acids,
people, animal foods such as eggs, fish, chicken, beef, and and accessory food factors. Refining of whole wheat to
dairy products can be healthfully consumed in moderation. white flour depletes most of the fiber and results in sub-
It is not necessary to consume animal foods to maintain stantial losses of vitamins and minerals (as noted in
good health. In fact, compared with omnivores, vegetari- Tables 2-1 and 2-2). In addition, more than half of the
ans have a lower risk of developing a number of chronic betaine is lost in the refining of whole wheat. Betaine
diseases. However, vegetarians must carefully plan their lowers homocysteine levels and might be of value for pre-
diet, so as not to develop nutritional deficiencies (see below venting cardiovascular disease.* Whole wheat and some
under Vegetarian diet). other whole grains (but not their refined counterparts) also
A balanced, whole-foods diet provides the nutrients that contain alkylresorcinols, a class of phenolic lipids that can
are essential for life and good health, including protein, be incorporated into cell membranes.* In rats, administra-
+ PART 1 * FUNDAMENTALS OF NUTRITIONAL MEDICINE
Table 2-1. Losses of vitamins in the refining of flour® of soy isoflavones (150 mg/day) for 5 years caused endo-
Vitamin Amount lost
metrial hyperplasia in 3.9% of women, although no endo-
metrial hyperplasia was seen after 2.5 years? (chapter 225).
Thiamine 11%
Riboflavin 80% Fruits and vegetables. Fruits and vegetables are rich
Niacin 81%
sources of vitamins, potassium and other minerals, carot-
Vitamin Be 72%
Pantothenic acid 50% enoids, flavonoids, fiber, and phytochemicals. Some veg-
Folic acid 67% etables are also good sources of essential fatty acids.
Vitamin E 86%
Choline 30%
Consumption of abundant amounts of fruits and vegetables
may be useful for preventing or treating cardiovascular dis-
ease, stroke, some cancers, hypertension, osteoporosis, and
other diseases.
Table 2-2. Losses of minerals in the refining of flour® With regard to specific fruits and vegetables, crucifer-
ous vegetables such as broccoli, Brussels sprouts, cab-
Mineral Amount lost
bage, kale, and cauliflower contain isothiocyanates and
Magnesium 85% indole-3-carbinol, which have demonstrated anticancer
Potassium 771% effects. In addition, indole-3-carbinol has been reported to
Calcium 60%
Iron 16%
be an effective treatment for cervical dysplasia. Onions
Zinc 78% may inhibit platelet aggregation, increase fibrinolytic activ-
Copper 68% ity, and lower blood pressure. Each of these effects would
Manganese 86%
Chromium 40%
be expected to reduce the risk of cardiovascular disease.
Selenium 16% Administration of tomato extracts has been shown to inhibit
Molybdenum 48% platelet aggregation and to lower blood pressure. In addi-
tion, tomatoes are a major food source of lycopene, which
may help prevent prostate cancer. Spinach, kale, and other
dark green leafy vegetables are good sources of lutein, a
tion of alkylresorcinols increased tissue concentrations of carotenoid that may help prevent age-related macular degen-
gamma-tocopherol,> a naturally occurring form of vitamin eration. However, spinach is also high in oxalate, and may
E that appears to have cardioprotective effects. In observa- therefore be contraindicated in people with calcium oxa-
tional studies, consumption of whole grains (as compared late kidney stones. Blueberries are a good source of antho-
with refined grains) has been associated with reduced risk cyanosides, which enhance capillary integrity and play a
of cardiovascular disease, stroke, and diabetes, and increased role in visual function. Cranberries contain compounds
longevity.°’’ For these reasons, whole grains are strongly that inhibit the binding of pathogenic Escherichia coli to
preferable to refined grains. uroepithelial cells. Cranberry juice and cranberry extracts
Beans and other legumes. Consumption of beans and other have been found to be effective for preventing urinary
legumes (e.g., lentils) has been reported to improve blood tract infections. Olives are rich in cardioprotective mono-
glucose regulation and to lower serum cholesterol levels. unsaturated fatty acids. Olives and extra virgin olive oil
Beans form a complete protein when combined with grains (but not refined olive oil) also contain a number of phe-
in a 1:3 ratio (dry weight). nolic antioxidants (oleuropein, hydroxytyrosol, vanillic acid,
Soy products, in addition to having the beneficial effects and verbascoside), which may have anti-inflammatory and
mentioned above, have been shown in some, but not all, cardioprotective effects.
studies to improve menopausal hot flashes and other Nuts. Nuts are a good source of protein, essential fatty
menopause-related symptoms (chapter 225). Soy foods have acids, magnesium, and fiber. Consumption of various types
also demonstrated an antihypertensive effect. In addition, of nuts has been shown to lower serum cholesterol levels.
soy may help prevent osteoporosis and some types of can- In observational studies, eating nuts was associated with a
cer, although the evidence is conflicting. Some of the effects lower incidence of cardiovascular disease. Since the poly-
of soy appear to be due to its content of isoflavones, which
unsaturated fatty acids in nuts can become oxidized to form
have both estrogenic and anti-estrogenic effects.
potentially toxic lipid peroxides, nuts should be stored in
On the negative side, soy is a relatively common aller-
an airtight container in the refrigerator. Nuts are best con-
gen. In addition, some practitioners have observed that pro- sumed raw and unsalted.
cessed soy can be difficult to digest, resulting in various
gastrointestinal symptoms. Soy products (particularly iso- Fish. Fish is a good source of protein, omega-3 fatty acids,
lated soy protein) have been shown to inhibit iron absorp- and other nutrients. Consumption of fish or fish oil has
tion, and soy appears to inhibit the absorption of levothyroxine been found to reduce the incidence of cardiovascular dis-
as well. In one study, treatment with a relatively high dose ease. Fish oil has an anti-inflammatory effect and has been
CHAPTER 2 * FUNDAMENTALS OF DIET 5
shown to be beneficial for the prevention and treatment of widely appreciated that high sugar intake or sensitivity to
a wide range of illnesses. Fish are at the top of the food refined sugar is in some cases a major contributing factor
chain and contain mercury and other toxins. However, the to a diverse array of symptoms and conditions, including
bulk of the evidence suggests that the benefits of moderate fatigue, anxiety, depression, migraines, tension headaches,
fish consumption (such as 2-3 servings a week) outweigh premenstrual syndrome, and candidiasis. Excessive sugar
the risks. consumption may also play a role in the pathogenesis of a
Meat and poultry. Meat and poultry contain substantial number of chronic diseases, including type 2 diabetes, non-
amounts of protein and heme iron (particularly red meat), alcoholic fatty liver disease, hypertension, and cardiovas-
as well as B vitamins, minerals, and carnitine. However, cular disease. The deleterious effects of refined sugar are
these foods are also high in cholesterol and saturated fat discussed further in the chapters on sucrose/high-fructose
and, being at the top of the food chain, tend to accumulate corn syrup (chapter 3) and reactive hypoglycemia (chapter 6).
pesticides and other toxic substances. Cooking meat and For many patients, eliminating or greatly reducing intake
of refined sugar is crucial for restoring health. The extent
poultry at high temperatures results in the production of
to which sugar intake must be restricted is assessed on an
carcinogens and advanced glycation end products (which
may promote the development of cardiovascular disease
individual basis.
and other diseases). The available evidence suggests that
meat and poultry should be used in moderation and cooked Other refined carbohydrates
at low temperatures, preferably in the presence of moisture
Refined grains should, whenever possible, be replaced by
(chapter 5). Meat from animals raised organically, without
whole grains (e.g., whole grain bread instead of white bread
the use of antibiotics and hormones, is preferable.
and brown rice instead of white rice). Refining of grains
Eggs. Eggs are a good source of high-quality protein, lutein, removes the nutrient-rich germ portion and the nutrient-
choline, and other nutrients. Although eggs are high in cho- and fiber-rich bran portion of the grain. Refined grains,
lesterol, egg consumption has little or no effect on serum which comprise approximately 30% of the calories in the
cholesterol levels in most people. In observational studies, American diet, contain substantially lower amounts of vita-
eating eggs was associated with an increased risk of heart mins, minerals, and fiber than do their unrefined counter-
disease in diabetics, but not in nondiabetics. Eggs should parts. In addition, the carbohydrates in refined grains are
be cooked in such a way as to minimize the formation of absorbed relatively rapidly and may therefore lead to less-
angiotoxic cholesterol oxides (i.e., boiling or poaching as than-optimal blood glucose control.
opposed to scrambling or frying).
Milk and dairy products. Cow’s milk is a good source of Caffeine
protein, calcium, and vitamin D. However, cow’s milk is
also one of the most common food allergens and, as such, Most adults ingest caffeine every day, primarily in coffee,
is a frequent etiological or triggering factor in a wide range tea, or cola drinks. Caffeine is often used to increase energy
of illnesses. In addition, cow’s milk consumption may play and alertness. In addition, caffeine is present as an adju-
a role in the pathogenesis of type | diabetes. vant in some analgesics, because it increases their potency
against various types of pain.!!
Because caffeine consumption is so widespread, there is
Refined sugars a tendency to overlook the fact that it is an addictive!* and
In addition to emphasizing the use of health-promoting foods, potentially toxic drug. While the research has not always
it is important for patients to restrict their intake of foods been consistent, caffeine consumption has been implicated
that cause symptoms and promote illness. At the top of the as a definite or possible contributing factor to reactive hypo-
list of undesirable foods is refined sugar, which is most glycemia, anxiety, panic attacks, insomnia, hypertension,
commonly consumed as sucrose and high-fructose corn fibrocystic breast changes, impaired fertility, headaches, car-
syrup. Nearly 20% of the calories in a typical American diac arrhythmias, gastroesophageal reflex disease, and other
diet are derived from added sugars (not including the sug- disorders.
ars that occur naturally in fruit, milk, and other foods). Sensitivity to caffeine differs substantially among differ-
This translates, according to one estimate, to an average of ent people. For example, individuals with panic disorder
about 40 teaspoons of added sugar per person per dayee and generalized anxiety disorder are especially sensitive to
and many people consume much more than that. Since the anxiety-inducing effects of caffeine.'*!4 Many people
refined sugar contains virtually no vitamins, minerals, or do not appear to suffer adverse effects from caffeine, and
other micronutrients, sugar consumption decreases overall some observational studies have found that caffeine con-
micronutrient intake by an average of almost 20%. sumption is associated with a reduced incidence of certain
It is generally agreed that excessive sugar consumption chronic diseases, including gallbladder disease, Parkinson’s
contributes to obesity and tooth decay. However, it is not disease, and type 2 diabetes. Nevertheless, caffeine toxic-
6 PART 1 * FUNDAMENTALS OF NUTRITIONAL MEDICINE
ity or intolerance should be included in the differential agricultural chemicals have been detected in a wide range
diagnosis of the various conditions listed above. of foods. Chemicals such as bisphenol A, phthalates, and
tin leach into foods and beverages from storage containers,
Alcohol and traces of antibiotics may be present in the meat and
milk of farm animals treated with antibiotics.
Excessive alcohol intake can contribute to a number of Potential consequences of widespread exposure to a mul-
disorders, including hepatitis, cirrhosis, cardiomyopathy, titude of man-made chemicals include allergic reactions,
depression, dementia, and nutritional deficiencies. It is widely disrupted cellular metabolism, overwhelmed detoxification
believed that moderate alcohol consumption (such as 1-2 mechanisms, and impaired immune function. Exposure to
drinks per day) is not harmful for most people, and may various chemicals has been implicated as a contributing
even reduce the risk of developing cardiovascular disease. factor to certain disorders, including attention deficit-
The purported cardioprotective effect of alcohol is based hyperactivity disorder, chronic urticaria, and diabetes. While
primarily on observational studies, and is open to debate it is possible in some cases to identify specific symptom-
(chapter 75). evoking chemicals by means of elimination-and-rechallenge
A substantial minority of patients appears to be particu- testing, identifying all offending chemicals can be a daunt-
larly sensitive to the deleterious effects of alcohol. These ing, if not impossible, task. Therefore, a reasonable strat-
patients are often the same ones who experience adverse egy would be to avoid as many additives and contaminants
effects from eating refined sugar. In these patients, consump- as possible. Patients who “clean up” their diet often observe
tion of moderate or even small amounts of alcohol may evoke various improvements in their health. The possible health
various physical and mental symptoms, trigger reactive hypo- effects of specific food additives and contaminants are dis-
glycemia, or aggravate conditions such as hypertension, gas- cussed further in chapter 4.
troesophageal reflux, psoriasis, or rosacea. The importance
of restricting alcohol intake is assessed on an individual basis.
Vegetarian diet
Fat Vegetarian diets are classified according to whether they con-
tain no animal products (vegan) or whether they include dairy
The role of dietary fat in the causation of cardiovascular
products and/or eggs (lacto-vegetarian, ovo-vegetarian, or
disease is discussed in chapter 75. The available evidence
lacto-ovo-vegetarian). Compared with omnivores, vegetar-
suggests that people should minimize their consumption of
ians have a lower incidence of a number of chronic dis-
trans fatty acids. People should also avoid using polyun-
eases, including cardiovascular disease, hypertension,
saturated fatty acids for frying or high-temperature cook-
gallbladder disease, kidney stones, diabetes, obesity, consti-
ing, in order to minimize the formation of potentially toxic
pation, and some cancers. Vegetarian diets also contain lower
lipid peroxides. As noted in chapter 75, saturated fats may
amounts of pesticides and other toxic chemicals than do
not be as harmful as is commonly believed, although some
omnivorous diets, since these chemicals tend to bioaccumu-
foods that are high in saturated fat may be atherogenic for
late in animal tissues. However, vegetarian diets may be low
reasons largely unrelated to their saturated fat content.
in a number of micronutrients, including vitamin B,>, iron,
vitamin D, zinc, iodine, riboflavin, calcium, and selenium.
Salt (sodium chloride) In addition, the protein in most plant foods is incom-
High salt intake can exacerbate hypertension, edema, and plete, in that it contains insufficient amounts of one or
congestive heart failure, and may be a risk factor for myo- more essential amino acids. Failure to provide adequate
cardial hypertrophy (independent of its effect on blood pres- amounts of any of the 8 essential amino acids limits the
sure) and kidney stones. By contrast, inadequate salt intake degree to which dietary protein can be utilized. This limi-
may lead to fatigue, postural hypotension, and insulin resis- tation can be overcome by proper food combining. For
tance. I advise most patients to use salt in moderation; i.e., example, grains are relatively deficient in lysine but con-
to avoid high-sodium foods and not to add large amounts tain abundant amounts of methionine, whereas beans are
of salt to food during cooking or at the table. More vigor- relatively deficient in methionine but contain abundant
ous sodium restriction is warranted for some patients, such amounts of lysine. When grains and beans are eaten together
as those with congestive heart failure. (usually in a 3:1 ratio, dry weight), these foods comple-
ment each other to form protein of similar biological value
to that of animal protein. It has been suggested that com-
Food additives and other contaminants
plementary proteins do not have to be eaten at the same
Hundreds of different chemicals are added to modern foods, meal in order to achieve the benefits of food combining.
including coloring and flavoring agents, preservatives, emul- However, since amino acids that are not utilized are catab-
sifiers, stabilizers, and thickeners. In addition, pesticides, olized (presumably in increasing amounts the longer they
herbicides, fungicides, plant growth regulators, and other remain unutilized), it would seem that combining comple-
CHAPTER 2 * FUNDAMENTALS OF DIET 7
mentary foods at the same meal would produce more effi- fewer gastrointestinal symptoms. Chewing food well also
cient protein utilization than would eating these foods at stimulates the production of saliva, which contains amy-
separate meals. lase (a digestive enzyme), substances that protect the gas-
Individuals interested in following a vegetarian diet may tric and esophageal mucosa (i.e., epithelial growth factor,
benefit from consulting a dietitian or nutritionist, in order mucin, transforming growth factor alpha, buffering agents,
to ensure that their diet is properly balanced and that they and prostaglandin E>),'° and compounds that help prevent
are receiving appropriate nutritional supplements. tooth decay (i.e., buffering agents, antibacterial com-
pounds, and calcium phosphate-binding proteins). There is
Food allergy truth in Horace Fletcher’s statement that “Nature will cas-
tigate those who don’t masticate.”
In my experience and that of numerous other practitioners,
hidden food allergy is one of the most common causes of a Eating breakfast. Several studies have demonstrated the
wide range of symptoms and conditions encountered in a importance of eating breakfast. In an observational study,
general medical practice. According to one estimate, as much food consumed in the morning, as compared with food
as 60% of the population suffers from undetected food aller- consumed later in the day, was associated with lower total
gy.'> In many cases, successful resolution of chronic health daily energy intake, suggesting that food eaten at breakfast
problems that have failed to respond to conventional ther- is particularly satiating.!’ In addition, eating breakfast has
apy depends largely on identifying and avoiding allergenic been associated with significant decreases in serum total-
foods. The failure of the conventional medical community and LDL-cholesterol levels, increased insulin sensitivity,'®
to acknowledge the importance (or even the existence) of possible improvement in performance on cognitive tasks,!?7°
hidden food allergy is, in my opinion, responsible for mil- and a lower incidence of gallstones.7!
lions of unsatisfactory clinical outcomes. The evaluation and Eating regularly. In a randomized controlled trial, an irreg-
management of hidden food allergy is discussed in chapter 7. ular meal pattern, as compared with eating regularly, resulted
in insulin resistance and higher total- and LDL-cholesterol
Water levels. Thus, eating regularly and not skipping meals may
Chlorine is added to municipal water supplies to kill micro-
confer health benefits.??
organisms. As discussed elsewhere in this book, chlorine A note on food addiction. While addiction to alcohol and
may be atherogenic and carcinogenic. Chlorine can be caffeine are widely recognized, it is not well appreciated
removed from tap water by a filter or by boiling or adding that many people are addicted to refined sugar and to foods
a pinch of vitamin C crystals to the water. Alternatives to to which they are allergic. Addiction to sugar and aller-
chlorination include ultraviolet irradiation and ozonation. genic foods is discussed in the chapter on obesity (chap-
Mountain spring water bottled in glass or hard plastic ter 333). I have found that counseling patients about the
may be an ideal choice for drinking water. Such water is addictive nature of refined sugar and allergenic foods; about
often rich in minerals and has generally fewer contami- the possibility that they will develop transient withdrawal
nants than water from underground springs and municipal symptoms (usually lasting 2—3 days); and about my avail-
water (which often contains aluminum). Water filtered by ability day or night should any untoward reactions occur
reverse osmosis is not recommended, because this process increases their success rate at withdrawing from these sub-
removes minerals, including ultra-trace minerals such as stances. Only rarely has anyone telephoned (and never in
rubidium, lithium, cobalt, and cesium, which are not included the middle of the night) regarding withdrawal symptoms.
in multimineral preparations, but which may turn out to
have important biological functions. References
1. Horwitz C, Walker ARP. Lignans—additional benefits from fiber? Nutr
Temperature of foods and beverages Cancer 1984;6:73-76.
2. Zeisel SH, Mar MH, Howe JC, Holden JM. Concentrations of choline-
containing compounds and betaine in common foods. J Nutr 2003;133:1302—1307.
Evidence from observational studies suggests that consump- 3. Vos E. Whole grains and coronary heart disease. Am J Clin Nutr
tion of very hot foods and beverages increases the risk of 2000;71:1009.
developing esophageal and gastric cancer. 4. Linko AM, Adlercreutz H. Whole-grain rye and wheat alkylresorcinols are
incorporated into human erythrocyte membranes. Br J Nutr 2005;93:11-13.
5. Ross AB, Chen Y, Frank J, et al. Cereal alkylresorcinols elevate gamma-
Dietary behavioral factors tocopherol levels in rats and inhibit gamma-tocopherol metabolism in vitro. J
Nutr 2004;134:506—5 10.
6. Liu S, Sesso HD, Manson JE, et al. Is intake of breakfast cereals related to
Mastication. In our zeal to provide the most advanced, total and cause-specific mortality in men? Am J Clin Nutr 2003;77:594-599.
sophisticated recommendations we sometimes forget to 7. Jacobs DR Jr, Meyer KA, Kushi LH, Folsom AR. Is whole grain intake
associated with reduced total and cause-specific death rates in older women?
emphasize basic factors such as the importance of chewing The Lowa Women’s Health Study. Am J Public Health 1999;89:322-329,
food thoroughly. Mastication breaks food down into smaller 8. Schroeder HA. Losses of vitamins and trace minerals resulting from pro-
particle sizes, leading to better digestion and in many cases cessing and preservation of foods. Am J Clin Nutr 1971;24:562-573.
8 PART 1 * FUNDAMENTALS OF NUTRITIONAL MEDICINE
9, Unfer V, Casini ML, Costabile L, et al. Endometrial effects of long-term 16. Sarosiek J, Scheurich CJ, Marcinkiewicz M, McCallum RW. Enhance-
treatment with phytoestrogens: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled ment of salivary esophagoprotection: rationale for a physiological approach
study. Fertil Steril 2004;82:145-148. to gastroesophageal reflux disease. Gastroenterology 1996;1 10:675—681.
10. Elliott SS, Keim NL, Stern JS, et al. Fructose, weight gain, and the 17. De Castro JM. The time of day of food intake influences overall intake in
insulin resistance syndrome. Am J Clin Nutr 2002;76:91 1-922. humans. J Nutr 2004;134:104-111.
11. Laska EM, Sunshine A, Mueller F, et al. Caffeine as an analgesic adju- 18. Farshchi HR, Taylor MA, Macdonald IA. Deleterious effects of omitting
vant. JAMA 1984;251:1711-1718. breakfast on insulin sensitivity and fasting lipid profiles in healthy lean women.
12. Strain EC, Mumford GK, Silverman K, Griffiths RR. Caffeine depen- Am J Clin Nutr 2005;81:388-396.
dence syndrome. Evidence from case histories and experimental evaluations. 19. Pollitt E, Leibel RL, Greenfield D. Brief fasting, stress, and cognition in
JAMA 1994;272:1043-1048. children. Am J Clin Nutr 1981;34:1526—1533.
13. Boulenger JP, Uhde TW, Wolff EA III, Post RM. Increased sensitivity to 20. Simeon D, Grantham-McGregor S. Cognitive function, undernutrition,
caffeine in patients with panic disorders. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1984;41: and missed breakfast. Lancet 1987;2:737-738.
1067-1071. 21. Capron JP, Delamarre J, Herve MA, et al. Meal frequency and duration
14. Bruce M, Scott N, Shine P, Lader M. Anxiogenic effects of caffeine in of overnight fast: a role in gall-stone formation? Br Med J 1981;283:1435.
patients with anxiety disorders. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1992;49:867—-869. 22. Farshchi HR, Taylor MA, Macdonald IA. Regular meal frequency creates
15. Breneman JC. Basics of Food Allergy. Springfield, IL, Charles C. Thomas, more appropriate insulin sensitivity and lipid profiles compared with irregular
1978:8. meal frequency in healthy lean women. Eur J Clin Nutr 2004;58:1071-1077.
This chapter provides a brief overview of the health effects Consumption patterns. Historically, sucrose and other
of the two most prevalent refined sugars in the Western refined sugars were consumed only in small quantities. For
diet: sucrose and high-fructose corn syrup (HFCS). Addi- example, estimated annual per capita sucrose consumption
tional information about the effects of these sugars is pro- was 6-8 pounds in the 1750s. This increased to about 25
vided in chapters related to specific disease conditions. pounds in the 1850s and to 120 pounds in the 1950s.! Over
Sucrose (commonly called table sugar) is a disaccharide the past few decades, a significant amount of the sucrose
derived from sugarcane and sugar beets. It consists of one in the Western diet has been replaced by HECS. As of
molecule of glucose and one molecule of fructose. HFCS 1997, mean annual per capita sucrose consumption had
contains fructose (55% by weight; 56.7% of total calories) decreased to 67 pounds, but mean total intake of these
and glucose (42% by weight; 43.3% of total calories) in refined sugars combined (sucrose plus HFCS) had increased
their monosaccharide forms. Pure fructose is also used in to 129 pounds, or about 40 teaspoons of added sugar per
some foods, but to a much lesser extent than sucrose and day. That level of intake corresponds to an average of
HFCS. These substances are collectively referred to in this 17-18% to more than 20% of total calories, depending on
chapter as refined sugars or added sugars, to distinguish the method of calculation. Many people consume refined
them from the relatively small amounts of fructose and sugar in amounts well above the average.
glucose present naturally in various fruits and vegetables.
Empty calories. Refined sugar contains virtually no vita-
Excessive consumption of sucrose and HFCS appears to
mins, minerals, or other micronutrients. Therefore, consump-
be an important contributing factor to many of the chronic
tion of refined sugar at the current level decreases overall
health problems that are prevalent in Western society. As
micronutrient intake by an average of at least 17-18%, and
discussed throughout this book, excessive intake of refined
by substantially more in some individuals. In addition, refined
sugar may promote or exacerbate obesity, type 2 diabetes,
sugars are energy-dense (i.e., they provide a large number
nonalcoholic fatty liver disease, hypertension, hypertriglyc-
of calories in a small volume) and contain no fiber. Because
eridemia, cardiovascular disease, kidney stones, chronic
it takes a relatively large number of calories from energy-
diarrhea/irritable bowel syndrome, gallbladder disease, tooth
dense foods to produce a feeling of fullness, excessive intake
decay, fatigue, anxiety, depression, attention deficit-
of sweets can lead to overeating and obesity.
hyperactivity disorder, migraines, tension headaches, pre-
menstrual syndrome, candidiasis, and other conditions. Dysglycemia and dysinsulinism. Refined sugar is absorbed
There are many similarities, but also some differences, rapidly into the bloodstream; a phenomenon the human
in the metabolic effects of sucrose and HFCS. Therefore, body was not apparently programmed to handle efficiently.
in this chapter these sugars will be discussed both collec- An abrupt rise in blood glucose levels may trigger the pan-
tively and separately. creas to release an excessive amount of insulin, which can
CHAPTER 3 * SUCROSE AND HIGH-FRUCTOSE CORN SYRUP 2
lead to reactive hypoglycemia (chapter 6) and a compen- compared with fructose) is probably related to the fact that
satory increase in the levels of blood sugar-raising com- the fructose portion of sucrose is not available for absorp-
pounds such as epinephrine and cortisol.* These and other tion until sucrose is hydrolyzed by intestinal brush border
disruptions of homeostatic mechanisms may contribute to enzymes. The fructose portion of sucrose is, therefore, pre-
the development of some of the symptoms and chronic sumably absorbed more slowly than fructose ingested as the
diseases listed above. monosaccharide.
There appears to be no evolutionary precedent for the
Other metabolic effects. Consumption of large amounts substantial increase in plasma fructose concentrations that
of sucrose may cause adverse changes in various cardio- results from eating high-fructose (and, to a somewhat lesser
vascular disease risk factors, including an increase in serum extent, high-sucrose) diets. Fructose is a powerful reduc-
levels of triglycerides, insulin, and uric acid; a rise in blood ing sugar, and therefore promotes the formation of advanced
pressure; an increase in platelet adhesiveness; and a decrease glycation end products, which may contribute to the aging
in HDL-cholesterol levels.4+° Approximately one-third of process and to the pathogenesis of cardiovascular disease
the population is susceptible to these adverse effects of and diabetic complications. In rats, ingestion of fructose
sucrose, and sucrose sensitivity appears to be clustered in or sucrose (but not glucose) increased tissue concentra-
people who have, or are at increased risk of developing, tions of advanced glycation end products.'* In addition,
cardiovascular disease.° Fructose consumption has been hyperfructosemia may deplete hepatic adenosine triphos-
reported to increase triglyceride and uric acid levels and to phate (ATP) levels (see chapter 124), with potential dele-
promote insulin resistance.’ terious consequence both for liver health and general
metabolism.
Immunological effects. Ingestion of 100 g (25 teaspoons)
of sucrose, glucose, or fructose by healthy volunteers caused Sucrose vs. HFCS. While excessive consumption of all
a transient decrease in the capacity of their neutrophils to types of refined sugar should be discouraged, a case can be
engulf bacteria.*? Ingestion of 75 g of glucose by healthy made that HFCS is somewhat more harmful than sucrose.
volunteers also transiently decreased measures of cell- One possible disadvantage of HFCS relative to sucrose is
mediated immune function.'? These findings raise the pos- the higher ratio of fructose to glucose in the former. This
sibility that limiting consumption of refined sugar would higher ratio would be expected to produce higher serum
be useful for preventing or treating infections. fructose concentrations, with potential deleterious conse-
quences as noted above. In addition, the monosaccharides
Gastrointestinal effects. Fructose malabsorption appears in HFCS are presumably absorbed more rapidly than the
to be a common, though underappreciated, cause of diar- sugars in sucrose, which must be hydrolyzed by intestinal
rhea and other symptoms often attributed to irritable bowel sucrase before being absorbed. More rapid absorption of
syndrome. The amount of fructose that can be absorbed as the glucose and fructose in HFCS might produce higher
a bolus varies widely among healthy volunteers, from 5 g peak serum concentrations of both of these sugars, adversely
to more than 50 g.'! Glucose enhances fructose absorption, affecting glycemic control and potentially disrupting other
and malabsorption of fructose typically occurs only if more homeostatic mechanisms.
fructose than glucose is present.!? Thus, gastrointestinal Of note, rats given fructose in their drinking water
symptoms may be more likely to occur with HFCS (which (250 g/L) showed signs of accelerated aging, whereas no
has a fructose-to-glucose ratio of 1.31 to 1, than with sucrose such effect was seen when the same amount of sucrose was
(which has a | to | ratio). However, sucrose consumption added to the drinking water.'> In addition, increases in the
has also been reported to cause chronic diarrhea, possibly prevalence of obesity, diabetes, and nonalcoholic fatty liver
through a mechanism unrelated to fructose malabsorption. disease over the past few decades have coincided with the
The effects of refined sugars on gastrointestinal symptoms partial replacement of sucrose with HFCS in the Western
are discussed further in chapters 104 and 113. diet.
6. Yudkin J, Szanto S, Kakkar VV. Sugar intake, serum insulin and platelet 11. Rumessen JJ, Gudmand-Hoyer E. Absorption capacity of fructose in healthy
adhesiveness in men with and without peripheral vascular disease. Postgrad adults. Comparison with sucrose and its constituent monosaccharides. Gut
Med J 1969;45:608—611. 1986;27:1161-1168.
7. Gaby AR. Adverse effects of dietary fructose. Altern Med Rev 2005;10: 12. Ament ME. Malabsorption of apple juice and pear nectar in infants and
294-306. children: clinical implications. J Am Coll Nutr 1996;15:26S-29S.
8. Sanchez A, Reeser JL, Lau HS, et al. Role of sugars in human neutro- 13. Macdonald I, Keyser A, Pacy D. Some effects, in man, of varying the
philic phagocytosis. Am J Clin Nutr 1973;26:1180-1184. load of glucose, sucrose, fructose, or sorbitol on various metabolites in blood.
9. Ringsdorf WM Jr, Cheraskin E, Ramsay RR Jr. Sucrose, neutrophilic phago- Am J Clin Nutr 1978;31:1305-1311.
cytosis and resistance to disease. Dent Survey 1976;52(12):46—48. 14. Werman MJ, Levy B. The chronic effect of dietary fructose intake on
10. Bernstein J, Alpert S, Nauss, KM, Suskind R. Depression of lympho- glycation and collagen cross-linking in rats. Am J Clin Nutr 1997;66:219.
cyte transformation following oral glucose ingestion. Am J Clin Nutr 1977; 15. Levi B, Werman MJ. Long-term fructose consumption accelerates glyca-
30:613. tion and several age-related variables in male rats. J Nutr 1998;128:1442-1449.
y Food additives
Our website is not just a platform for buying books, but a bridge
connecting readers to the timeless values of culture and wisdom. With
an elegant, user-friendly interface and an intelligent search system,
we are committed to providing a quick and convenient shopping
experience. Additionally, our special promotions and home delivery
services ensure that you save time and fully enjoy the joy of reading.
ebookname.com