add(library): usva. - #681
Conversation
dunnbot
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Thanks for the thorough writeup — the design work here is clearly considered, and I verified the tokens do ship as a Tailwind CSS v4 @theme block, which is the thing I care most about for this list.
A few items to resolve before it can go in:
-
usvaisn't on npm yet. The registry 404s forusva; onlyusva-tokensis published. Your own docs flag the npm path as pending until the package is live. I'd rather list this once the install path most people will use actually works. -
License.
LICENSE.mdis MIT + Commons Clause, which makes this source-available rather than open source — the list requires items to be free and open to use. Free to use inside an application it plainly is, and the restriction is only on reselling the components themselves, so I don't think this is clear-cut. I want to be deliberate about where Commons Clause lands before it becomes precedent here. Happy to hear your reasoning. -
📚🧩isn't a combination the list uses. In that section only 💙 pairs with a type emoji; every other entry carries exactly one of 📚 / 🧩 / 📁. Pick whichever fits better and place the entry at the bottom of that emoji group. -
Drop the trailing period from the link text.
[usva.]would be the only entry in the list with punctuation inside the name, and it reads awkwardly against the required[Item name](link) - Description.shape. I understand it's the brand styling, but the list format wins here. -
components library→component library, and consider naming React in the description. As written, someone scanning the list can't tell what they'd be installing — the guide's own example is "React UI library using Tailwind CSS."
Push those up and ping me once the package is live, and I'll take another look.
|
Heads up: #682 just merged into the same spot in the 📚 group, so this now conflicts. You'll need a rebase on |
|
@dunnbot on the license - usva is free to use anywhere, commercially included, and you can fork it or copy a component's source out of the registry and own it outright. the only thing not allowed is reselling the components themselves as the product. it's not OSI-open, but the section already lists tailwind plus and catalyst, so free-to-use looks like the working bar. package is live on npm as well (as @usva-ui/react and @usva-ui/tokens) |
|
Thanks for turning those around quickly — the emoji, the trailing period, the grammar and the React naming are all correct now, and I confirmed On the license, I'm going to decline, and I want to give you the honest reasoning rather than a one-liner. Tailwind Plus and Catalyst aren't precedent. Those are Tailwind Labs' own resources. They're on the list under the 💙 marker as official resources, and they're there out of respect for the team that builds and gives away Tailwind CSS itself. That's a deliberate carve-out for the people whose work this entire list exists to catalogue, and it doesn't extend outward to third-party projects. They're the two entries you'd least be able to reason from. Auditing the rest of that section against the same bar turned up two entries of my own that fail it. Preline carries a non-compete rider on top of MIT, and Kometa's license strikes the sublicensing and resale rights. That's an inconsistency on my side rather than a standard anyone gets to inherit, so I'm opening a PR to remove them. The bar gets applied evenly, not just against the newest submission. The bar going forward: for third-party items, an OSI-approved open source license. Commons Clause is explicitly not one — it's the canonical example of a source-available rider, and your own commit history calls it that. "Free to use in an app" isn't the same as "free and open to use," and I'd rather this list mean one specific thing than shade toward "free enough." None of this is a judgment on the work. The design system is genuinely thoughtful, the token architecture is real, and the Tailwind CSS v4 |
Design language and component library in three themes: atmospheric, dense, or light, from one token vocabulary. The tokens ship as a Tailwind v4
@themeblock. It works as registry copy-in, so a Tailwind user can take one component without adopting the whole component library.