Limit peer review (and "Nominate for deletion") to users above level 5

[nicolas-raoul]

Peer review can not be done by a beginner. It takes quite some experience to know what is on-topic and off-topic, what is a copyright violation or not.

So, I suggest hiding the navigation drawer's "Review" item from users who have not yet reached level 10.

I chose 10 because it is a round number, but I am open to other suggestions.

This means storing the level somewhere when it is retrieved from the server (in the Achievements activity). People who have never opened the Achievements activity will not see the "Review" item, because their level is unknown.

[madhurgupta10]

@nicolas-raoul Instead of hiding, what if we have a dialog which tells the user why he/she can't review, this will motivate him/her to reach next levels quickly :)

[neslihanturan]

This means storing the level somewhere when it is retrieved from the server (in the Achievements activity). People who have never opened the Achievements activity will not see the "Review" item, because their level is unknown.

If we will implement this, we can calculate achievements on background on application start. Or as @madhurgupta10 said, we can inform user. We can first "if you like to discover review item please check your achievement score first, and redirect user to achievements", on next visit if they are under the score inform that why we have such mechanism. If they exceed, let them review.

But this should be designed carefully because saying "you are not eligible to review" may be understood as a rude/annoying expression.

[nicolas-raoul]

@madhurgupta10 Indeed, displaying the button and showing an explanation can be a way to motivate people, indeed. We don't want to make people play the system, though, for instance by uploading 1000 picture of a mushroom and embedding them all in sub-pages of the Swahili Wikipedia, for instance.

@neslihanturan You are right. I am confident that we can do this in a careful way. StackOverflow has tons of level-specific privileges and manages to not make them feel rude. https://stackoverflow.com/help/privileges

[misaochan]

Good idea! But umm, is level 10 a bit high? Maybe 5 or something...? I think you are the only one here who has level 10+, @nicolas-raoul . ;)

[nicolas-raoul]

Yes sure, 5 is probably enough.
But if it is only to allow developers to performs tests, then maybe implementing #2861 is safer strategy? :-)

[misaochan]

Not really for the developers, I just thought that 10 is a bit too high. :) Devs can always hardcode or mock their level with the debugger.

[madhurgupta10]

@nicolas-raoul @misaochan Can I start implementing this?

[nicolas-raoul]

@madhurgupta10 Sure, thanks! :-)