Skip to content

Possible drop of support of using themr as decorator with TypeScript #71

Open
@raveclassic

Description

@raveclassic

Currently I'm trying to rewrite themr in TS to provide consistent up-to-date typings and I'm in the middle of the struggle started in #39
The problem is that switching from correct React.ComponentClass<P> to component constructor type (with new()) is completely broken with strictNullChecks on, here's my comment

@themr('foo') //error - Type 'null' is not assignable to type 'Element'
class FooClass extends React.Component<any, any> {
	render()/*: JSX.Element | null //ok when uncommented*/ {
		return <div>hi</div>;
	}
}

Moreover, decorating a class with @themr complains on every lifecycle method (like componentWillMount) of decorated class as TS can't cast it to ComponentClass. On the other hand, calling themr as a function on existing class works fine - seems like decorators are broken in TS.
Well, at least they are still behind experimental flag.

@mpodlasin @odensc Could you please check if you do use decorators instead of composing HOCs separately from actual component class or sfc which is more natural for react ecosystem in general especially when using recompose?

If it's ok for you and if it's worth dropping experimental decorators, I would open a PR with a fresh new themr fully in typescript.

The good news are that now I'm finally able to overwrite props in decorated component with their non-necessary versions, thanks to this comment
So that themed component does not require theme object to be passed via props but still checks its type if it is present.

UPDATE: still it will be possible and absolutely transparent to use themr as decorator for current ES6 users.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions