[css-shapes-1] Updated CR of CSS Shapes?

[svgeesus]

The ED dates to 20 May 2021 and lists substantive changes since the previous CR of 2014. (commit history)

Time for an updated CR?

[svgeesus]

@atanassov @astearns

[svgeesus]

@atanassov @astearns ?

implementation report

[svgeesus]

The wpt implementation report is more comprehensive.

[svgeesus]

So, this 2014 CR is badly in need of republication. There have been a bunch of edits and the changes section is not up to date. The Security/Privacy section needs to be split in two.

Ideally <wpt> markup should be added to indicate tested sections, but that work should not hold up republication.

I suggest publishing a CR Draft, then doing horizontal review, followed by CR Snapshot.

[svgeesus]

I went through the commit history (including the commit history before it was renamed and when it used the pre-bikeshed .src format), checking all commits against the changes section and adding any that had been missed. The changes section is now complete.

I also split Privacy and Security considerations into two, as required for horizontal review, and added a link to the implementation report

There is one linking error, because the old <length-percentages> production is used but it no longer exists. But that is an easy fix. Apart from that, this spec looks in good shape for CR Draft.

[svgeesus]

There is one linking error, because the old production is used but it no longer exists. But that is an easy fix.

Fixed

[svgeesus]

changes section on w3c.github.io

[astearns]

Meeting notes since the bot missed them

RESOLVED: Publish css-shapes-1 CRD

<fantasai> Topic: [css-shapes-1] Updated CR of CSS Shapes? Administrative Tracker For external review / publication tracking issues
<chris> q+
<fantasai> chris: I'm whining about this thing not being published since 2014
<fantasai> chris: I went through all the commits since 2014 and updated the Changes list
<fantasai> chris: added implementation, split privsec section
<fantasai> chris: I think this is ready to go
<•astearns> q+
<fantasai> astearns: Thanks so much for doing that work
<fantasai> astearns: My preference would have been to get the edits for reconciling with gradient syntax first, but since you've done this work, I'm happy to publish now and republish later with the edits
<fantasai> chris: sounds good to me
<fantasai> chris: If you thought those edits would be timely that would be fine, but if you think it'll confuse people
<fantasai> astearns: No, I am now good for publishing and I can't guarantee that my edits will be timely
<fantasai> Rossen_: +1, thanks for the help chris this is great
<fantasai> Rossen_: objections to publish CRD?
<fantasai> RESOLVED: Publish css-shapes-1 CRD
<fantasai> Rossen_: again, thanks Chris, for doing the work

[svgeesus]

The CSS Working Group just discussed [css-shapes-1] Updated CR of CSS Shapes?.

The full IRC log of that discussion

<fantasai> chris: I'm whining about this thing not being published since 2014
<fantasai> chris: I went through all the commits since 2014 and updated the Changes list
<fantasai> chris: added implementation, split privsec section
<fantasai> chris: I think this is ready to go
<@astearns> q+
* Zakim sees chris, astearns on the speaker queue
* fantasai ack chris
* Zakim sees astearns on the speaker queue
<Rossen_> ack chris
* fantasai ack astearns
* Zakim sees astearns on the speaker queue
* Zakim sees no one on the speaker queue
<Rossen_> ack astearns
* Zakim sees no one on the speaker queue
<fantasai> astearns: Thanks so much for doing that work
<fantasai> astearns: My preference would be to get the edits for reconciling with gradient syntax first, but since you've done this work, I'm happy to publish now and republish later with the edits
<fantasai> chris: sounds good to me
<fantasai> chris: If you thought those edits would be timely that would be fine, but if you think it'll confuse people
<fantasai> astearns: No, I am now good for publishing and I can't guarantee that my edits will be timely
<fantasai> Rossen_: +1, thanks for the help chris this is great
<fantasai> Rossen_: objections to publish CRD?
<fantasai> RESOLVED: Publish css-shapes-1 CRD
<fantasai> Rossen_: again, thanks Chris, for doing the work

RESOLVED: Publish css-shapes-1 CRD