[motion-1] Publish an updated WD or move to CR

[SebastianZ]

Motion Path 1 was last published in 2018.

At the same time it is part of Interop 2023 and received several substantial changes since then, which UAs already started to implement.

Therefore, a new WD should be published. Because it received a bunch of WPT updates and UAs working on interoperability, it may also be moved to CR instead.

Sebastian

[svgeesus]

It would be preferable to publish an updated WD soon. Then call for horizontal review.

The, when requesting CR, a recent WD means that it is easier to claim that the spec has had wide review and that the changes between WD and CR are few.

[css-meeting-bot]

The CSS Working Group just discussed Motion L1, and agreed to the following:

• RESOLVED: Add fantasai as editor to Motion L1 and publish WD

The full IRC log of that discussion

<fantasai> Topic: Motion L1
<fantasai> github: https://github.com//issues/9165
<fantasai> astearns: Plan is to publish WD, then call for Horizontal Review, and get it to CR asap
<fantasai> astearns: Anyone have anything to add?
<fantasai> astearns: Anyone willing to help Tab?
<fantasai> astearns: It's easy, almost done!
<fantasai> [no one says anything]
<fantasai> fantasai: I can help out
<fantasai> astearns: but not you! j/k it's fine
<fantasai> astearns: propose to add fantasai as editor to Motion 1 so we have backup
<fantasai> astearns: also any objections to new WD of Motion 1?
<fantasai> RESOLVED: Add fantasai as editor to Motion L1 and publish WD

[astearns]

ACTION on the editors to ask for wide review once the WD is published

[svgeesus]

@fantasai how is publication going?

[svgeesus]

So this publication seems to have slipped through the cracks. Meanwhile there have been lots of updates since 2018. Also @jihyerish Jihye Hong has changed affiliation to Igalia, and Eric Willigers is no longer in the CSS WG so should be moved to previous editors.

[svgeesus]

I cleaned up the list of editors but will leave @fantasai to add herself.

[svgeesus]

I added changes since 2018

[svgeesus]

At the same time it is part of Interop 2023

[svgeesus]

I added WPT annotations.

[svgeesus]

There are currently 11 open issues on motion-1 it would be good to address these (or punt them to a future level) before moving to CR

[svgeesus]

Publication requested 31 Oct 2024, expected (after publishing moratorium ends) 5 Nov 2024

[svgeesus]

Published 5 Nov 2024